Monday, September 24, 2012

The Troubled World of International Aid and a Reflection on Rotary

A moment I will never forget was perhaps my most disheartening moment of the year, and yet, my proudest moment of Rotary. 

A friend and I were at dinner with two gentlemen from Geneva who were doing fieldwork in Ghana as part of a nutrition-focused NGO. They asked about my research work in Accra and my background in geochemistry and health. Laughing, they said that their NGO could probably use that background in geochemistry even though the NGO dealt with nutrition. One mentioned that though he knew nothing about nutrition- having background in international development- he has set the fortification standards for five countries, a fact he admitted was scary. Both men looked at me morosely and uttered, “Never go humanitarian.” 

The men talked of their frustration with large international organizations that have problems sticking to their code of ethics and problems making sustainable projects. They said they have been kicked out of meetings because they stood up to the authorities. They said they have seen schools built where uneducated teachers were brought in to teach. They said there is too much money to be made by keeping people poor and hungry. They said it has destroyed their childhoods.

This news was Earth-shattering to me, especially as someone who envisioned working with such an organization in the future. At this moment, I finally realized what was so incredibly special and unique about Rotary. It was exactly what has confused me about Rotary in the past. I was always uneasy about the business and networking aspects of Rotary, that Rotarians were often well-to-do, with comfortable salaries and prominent careers. How much could these people know about suffering? It was almost as if Rotarians were conservative hippies- business people who still wanted world peace. Then it hit me. Rotarians use their careers for humanitarian purposes; the humanitarian work is not necessarily their careers. This set-up is ingenious. The world needs well-to-do people who also care about hunger, poverty, and education. For instance, take Rotary’s six main areas of focus: peace and conflict resolution, disease prevention and treatment, water and sanitation, maternal and child health, basic education and literacy, and economic and community development. They recognize it is in everyone’s best interest to address these issues. Rotarians can have dignity in their careers, whatever they may be, then also find dignity in how they use their careers for service. This is why Rotary projects are so sustainable. When I met William Boyd, the chair of the Rotary Foundation, he said that Rotary projects are about 95% sustainable, which is tremendously successful. This level of sustainability makes sense: for one, Rotarians have a background of skills and knowledge, and secondly, they have no reason to try to make a project that will only work for the short-term. I had never been so proud of Rotary than at the end of that evening. It all finally made sense.

No comments:

Post a Comment